Deleting Kashmir From Ufa Joint Statement
Punchline ‘Statements’ and History By Z. G. Muhammad Crooked historians cannot change the history. Like ripe pods spilling beans, history ultimately reveals the truth. In the joint statement issued a fortnight back after the summit meeting between Prime Ministers, Narendra Modi and Mian Nawaz Sharif, at Ufa, Russia, there is no mention about Kashmir. The meeting was held, after eleven months diplomatic standoff. New Delhi, had called off the Secretary Level talks in August 2014 in protest against Pakistan High Commissioner, New Delhi meeting the Hurriyat leaders for taking them on board before the talks- a practice in vogue for past many years. It sounded, ironic when Pakistan team in Ufa agreed to delete Kashmir from the joint statement. Many important Pakistani analysts and seasoned diplomat pooh-poohed Nawaz Sharif and his team for … Read entire article »
Filed under: Editor's Take
Nineties and Dulat’s Book- Reading Between Lines?
PUNCHLINE Behind The Lid Off Z.G. Muhammad Memoirs are important for telling the whole story about political struggles. Not only the memoirs of the major dramatis personae involved in the struggles are important for the narratives of the struggling nations but even stories told by those involved in subverting these struggles help in telling the whole story. True, there are instances like, ‘A Million Little Pieces’ by James Frey promoted and sold as memoirs later discovered … Read entire article »
Filed under: Editor's Take
Story of Shimla Agreement
Truth About Shimla Agreement Z.G. Muhammad Forty three years back on 2 July at Shimla, a bilateral agreement was signed between India and Pakistan. Since their birth as independent dominions the two countries have signed number of agreements some under international umbrellas and some under auspices of friendly countries. But, out of all the agreements between the two countries, New Delhi has been attaching lot of importance to this agreement and has been looking at it, as … Read entire article »
Filed under: Editor's Take
Trifurcation – A Discourse from Jammu
PUNCHLINE Discordant Discourses Z.G. Muhammad Kashmir, for past sixty seven years has been a cauldron of the ‘dominant’ discourses. In forties and fifties, the Communists ideologues conjured alternative discourse to erode the people’s narrative born in 1924. That was in concrete terms manifested in the 1932 resolution adopted on the founding day of the Jammu and Kashmir Muslim Conference. For subverting the Kashmir narrative, in fifties, the Hindu nationalists stirred agitation in Jammu against symbols of Kashmiri … Read entire article »
Filed under: Editor's Take, Point of view
Setting thaw through ‘Kitty-Party’ Initative
PUNCHLINE ‘Kitty Party’ Initiative Z.G. Muhammad All is not well between India and Pakistan. If the recent statements of Defence Minister, Manohar Parrikar and Home Minister Raj Nath Singh during their visit to Srinagar and Jammu are indicators the two countries are on a collision course. The optimisms, for good relation spawned one year back during a meeting between Narendra Modi and Nawaz Sharif did not last long- it in fact crashed immediately. Sharif had travelled to New Delhi to participate in oath taking ceremony of new Indian Prime Minister. However the flicker of hope persisted. Sharif taking a departure from the stated position of his country had exhibited extraordinary enthusiasm for improving trade links with India. The statement by the two ministers did not stir much of a serious reaction from Pakistan … Read entire article »
Filed under: Editor's Take
Why Sheikh Abdullah Exiled Intellectuals.
PUNCHLINE Kashmir Intellectuals Exiled to Pakistan? Z.G. Muhammad It is ‘power of ideas’ and intellectual inputs that work as catalysts in bringing about political changes. Historically, majority of our leaders from the towering to the dwarfish, have been averse to the ideas and inputs from thinking minds. In fact, after mid-forties to this day intolerance towards intellectual discourse about the political struggles or the movement has been basic principle of a powerful section of the tribe. People … Read entire article »
Filed under: Editor's Take
Munshi Ishaq Has Demolishes Myths About Leaders- My Take
Presentation on Book Nidaa-e-Haque By Z.G. Muhammad Chairperson: Dr. Sheikh Mohammad Iqbal, Guest of Honor, Dr. Altaf Hussain, man of the moment Munshi Ghulam Hassan – and distinguished scholars and friends. It is a moment of pride for me, to have been invited to present my take on the memoirs of a great son of the soil Munshi Mohammad Ishaq – one of the towering leaders of Kashmir’s struggle against autocracy and in the post 1947 scenario a powerful … Read entire article »
Filed under: Editor's Take, Featured