Fetters on Scholarship. Why?
Z.G. Muhammad ‘Kashmir University has become an extension of the ‘state establishment. Moreover, academic freedom and genuine scholarship is the biggest causality.’ This lament has been finding an echo in most of the academic seminars held outside the campus. On 10 December 2014, when across the world people were observing the Human Rights Day and pledging to uphold all the thirty Articles contained in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, in a seminar some scholars, researchers and students were raising their voice against denial of academic freedom in the Kashmir University. This seminar had been organized by a group of civil society to mark the historic day. Scholars mostly from social sciences and languages narrated stories after stories about their being coerced to change their findings and bringing them in line with … Read entire article »
Filed under: Editor's Take
Article 370 and UN Resolutions are “dove-tailed”
Punchline 370 and United Nations By Z. G. Muhammad Thank you Narendra Modi for sparking a debate on the Article 370 of the Indian Constitution and its application to Jammu and Kashmir. There can be no debate on the Article, in isolation of the 1947 and the ‘accession story of Kashmir’. Your statement prompted some political leaders subscribing to the ‘finality of the accession of the state to Indian Union’ to look afresh on the article. You also made … Read entire article »
Filed under: Editor's Take
With Deference Something For Jumpy Kashmir Leaders
PUNCHLINE ‘Political fatigue and surrendering the cherished political causes for which leaders have whipped up public sentiments, mobilized millions to come on the streets and made people to suffer immensely is neither pragmatism nor realpolitik’ . This was central theme of my column, ‘the story of climb-downs’, published two weeks back in this newspaper. To illustrate, how the ‘climbing-down syndrome’ afflicting our leadership had defeated the resolution of the Kashmir Dispute and worked as dampener for bringing in lasting peace in South-Asia, I had quoted examples of the 1964 Holy Relic Movement and Sheikh-Nehru Dialogue, the 1965, students agitation and civil disobedience movement, the 1968 State Peoples Convention and the 1975 Indira-Sheikh Agreement. Nevertheless, for limitations of space, I had not been able to dwell in detail, how our leadership had … Read entire article »
Filed under: Editor's Take
The Politics of Boycotts in J&K
Z.G. MUHAMMAD Everyone has right to his dreams- even pipe dreams. Jamal – the great hashish smoker in our locality too had his dreams. Many times, sitting on shop fronts, he soliloquized and made his dream of becoming the chief executive of the state and replacing the “tailor’s son”, known to passersby and dizzy friends sharing his pipe. Jamal committed no sin, anyone can dream of becoming the chief executive- And for wishing to be the chief executive or getting a berth in temple of “democracy” there is no need for stoking a debate or conjuring discourses that are not holistically in conformity with the with historical realities and run contrary to the established ‘Kashmir narrative.’ ‘Is boycotting the elections right politics or participation in 2014 Assembly election is the correct option.’ … Read entire article »
Filed under: Editor's Take
Ireland and Kashmir are incomparable
Z. G. MUHAMMAD It will be to be too prophetic to say on what signature tune curtains will be drawn on the year 2013 in Kashmir. Fifty-seven days left of the current year ostensibly are too small a period to expect dramatic political changes in a state caught up in uncertainties for over sixty-six years. Nevertheless, in disputes like that of Jammu and Kashmir even a small incident can presage a big change. The last week of October 2013 was significant in as much as generating a debate over landing of Indian troops on 27 October 1947 at Srinagar airport. The debate was marked by renewed discourse on ‘date and fact’ of the “Instrument of Accession” that had ‘facilitated’ India to send its troops into Jammu and Kashmir- then an independent country. … Read entire article »
Filed under: Editor's Take
Third Party Mediation and Kashmir
Z.G. MUHAMMAD It is not a beaten path. That columnists and commentators in the subcontinent in general and Jammu and Kashmir in particular- on both the sides of the dividing line love to tread on October 27 every year for heck of it. Today also, the date runs through Kashmir narrative. On this day in 1947, men in olive green from New Delhi landed at 9.00 A.M at Srinagar aerodrome. Sorties after sorties of planeloads of soldiers raising clouds of dust landed until the sunset. Ever since, with some historians holding view Kashmir dispute was born on this day it has been a matter of debate and discussion with scholars, researchers and commentators. Sixty five years after, the date continues to be central to the Kashmir narrative. The Kashmir dispute not only continues … Read entire article »
Filed under: Editor's Take
Mir Saiyed Ali Hamadani- A Lodestar
Z. G. MUHAMMAD It was a day of introspection. Sitting through a one-day seminar on Mir Sayed Ali Hamadani in Kashmir University, on Wednesday, I was reminded of my identity- Who am I? Pat came the reply, I am an aborigine born in a Muslim family. Brought up in a Muslim family in a very large a seminary- the “old” Srinagar city that was adopted not only as the capital by the Sultans of Kashmir but also as a great centre of Islamic learning. Even after the Sikh rulers in 1819, closed the five hundred year old Islamic institutions, the city lived to the tradition of being a large seminary- where almost everyone received education in basic tenets of Islam from the pulpits. I was reminded of my debt to Mir … Read entire article »
Filed under: Editor's Take